BrockN
Well-known member
- First Name
- Brock
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2025
- Threads
- 6
- Messages
- 354
- Reaction score
- 521
- Location
- Kamloops BC Canada
- Vehicles
- '24 FS Cybertruck, '23 MY, '15 MS
- Occupation
- Engineer
- Thread starter
- #1
Yes, just what the forum needed - yet another tire thread!
I swapped my OEM Territory RT's for the winter package Duratracs yesterday. You can procrastinate on the swap when your 'summer' tire is pretty much a winter tread, but I finally got to it.
Sidebar: I picked up this thing to make the job easier - https://tireliftcaddy.com/ and was satisfied. So was my back.
I measured the tread depth on the Territory tires I removed and realized I hadn't measured them when they were new. That sent me down a rabbit hole as the wisdom on the net seems to say they came with anywhere between 9/32 and 11/32 of an inch but was not definitive. Not very much tread, compared with the Duratrac set! I'm down to 6,7,8 (inside, middle, outside) rear and 7,9,8 front, so I'm not believing the OEM 9/32 suggestion.
Anyway, they have 10,000 km on them now and might last another season, but with minimal tread remaining. My use case benefits from a bit more tread, so I think they'll be getting replaced before too long. That got me into a discussion with ChatGPT that might be of interest to some people. Note that my summer average was 233 Wh/km. ChatGPT did a fairly extensive dive looking for efficiency information, but I haven't checked sources to determine how accurate it is. My gut check says it's probably pretty close to reality. The Duratrac numbers trac(k) my experience last winter, although the Toyo results seem a bit too good to be true.
The response following is probably the most interesting part of the chat:
Perfect â letâs extend your Goodyear Territory RT = 0% baseline efficiency chart to include the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT (Teslaâs winter package) category, using your real baseline of 233 Wh/km and keeping everything normalized to that.
Assumptions
Rolling Resistance / Efficiency Comparison
Interpretation
After all of this, I'm really wishing Tesla allowed you to specify a different tire from the one they supply. I now have two sets of tires and wheels and would much prefer an efficient tire of my choice that would work year round. That would save me the tire swap work twice a year and also free up a bit of space in the garage. Tant pis...
I swapped my OEM Territory RT's for the winter package Duratracs yesterday. You can procrastinate on the swap when your 'summer' tire is pretty much a winter tread, but I finally got to it.
Sidebar: I picked up this thing to make the job easier - https://tireliftcaddy.com/ and was satisfied. So was my back.
I measured the tread depth on the Territory tires I removed and realized I hadn't measured them when they were new. That sent me down a rabbit hole as the wisdom on the net seems to say they came with anywhere between 9/32 and 11/32 of an inch but was not definitive. Not very much tread, compared with the Duratrac set! I'm down to 6,7,8 (inside, middle, outside) rear and 7,9,8 front, so I'm not believing the OEM 9/32 suggestion.
Anyway, they have 10,000 km on them now and might last another season, but with minimal tread remaining. My use case benefits from a bit more tread, so I think they'll be getting replaced before too long. That got me into a discussion with ChatGPT that might be of interest to some people. Note that my summer average was 233 Wh/km. ChatGPT did a fairly extensive dive looking for efficiency information, but I haven't checked sources to determine how accurate it is. My gut check says it's probably pretty close to reality. The Duratrac numbers trac(k) my experience last winter, although the Toyo results seem a bit too good to be true.
The response following is probably the most interesting part of the chat:
Perfect â letâs extend your Goodyear Territory RT = 0% baseline efficiency chart to include the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT (Teslaâs winter package) category, using your real baseline of 233 Wh/km and keeping everything normalized to that.
- Vehicle: Cybertruck AWD Foundation
- Baseline energy: 233 Wh/km on OE Goodyear Territory RT
- All comparisons use the same driving mix you described (mixed pavement + gravel + winter use)
- Percentages are realistic, not marketingâbased on EV user data and tread design characteristics.
| Tire / Category | Type / Intent | Est. Î vs OEM Territory RT | Est. Wh/km | Key Trade-offs & Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goodyear Wrangler Territory RT | OE All-Terrain / Hybrid RT | 0 % (Baseline) | 233 | Shallow tread (â 10-11 â 32âł), light weight, fair efficiency; short life (~20 k km) |
| Michelin Defender LTX / Platinum | Highway All-Season / Low RR LT | â 4 % (â more efficient) | 224 | Best efficiency + longevity, quiet, limited off-road |
| Toyo Open Country A/T III EV | EV-optimized All-Terrain | â 3 % | 226 | Very balanced: mild A/T grip with EV-friendly RR |
| Nokian Outpost nAT | All-Terrain / All-Weather (3PMSF) | + 2.5 % | 239 | Strong winter & gravel performance, modest energy penalty |
| Toyo Open Country A/T III (standard) | Conventional A/T | + 4.5 % | 244 | Deeper tread, more bite, moderate RR penalty |
| Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT (Tesla Winter Pkg) | Aggressive A/T / Winter (3PMSF) | + 6 â 9 % | 247 â 254 | 18 â 32âł tread, heavy LT construction, excellent snow & FSR traction; noticeable range drop |
| Falken Wildpeak A/T4W / Nitto Recon Grappler | Heavy-Duty A/T | + 7.5 % | 251 | Deeper tread & weight â noise + efficiency loss for durability |
- Your 233 Wh/km baseline sits between âhighwayâ and âmild A/T.â
- The DuraTrac RT Tesla winter tire is an aggressive 3PMSF A/T, roughly +6â9 % higher rolling resistance than your Territory RT.
- That means your energy draw could rise to ~247â254 Wh/km in typical conditions.
- On 20 000 km / yr, thatâs about +340 â 420 kWh extra per year â $43 â $53 more at BC Hydro rates.
- Youâd trade that extra energy for far superior snow, ice, and deep-gravel grip plus much longer tread life.
After all of this, I'm really wishing Tesla allowed you to specify a different tire from the one they supply. I now have two sets of tires and wheels and would much prefer an efficient tire of my choice that would work year round. That would save me the tire swap work twice a year and also free up a bit of space in the garage. Tant pis...
Sponsored